Four Nigerian government-backed projects associated with approximately $857 million in external financing have been linked to abandoned infrastructure, incomplete programmes and underperforming public services.

The findings were published in an October 30 BusinessDay investigation, which examined the performance of earlier loan-funded projects as President Bola Tinubu seeks parliamentary approval for additional foreign borrowing.

The proposed financing comprises $20.52 billion and €1.045 billion for projects scheduled under the government's 2026–2027 supplementary external borrowing plan.

The president's request, presented to the Senate on October 27, covers investments in electricity, transportation, healthcare, agriculture, education, water supply and national security.

However, the investigation raises a fundamental concern: Nigeria has previously borrowed substantial amounts for infrastructure that has not delivered the services promised to citizens.

Where did the $857 million go?

The investigation examined four projects financed or supported through foreign loans.

The largest was the National Public Security Communications System, backed by a $399.5 million loan from the Export-Import Bank of China.

Awarded in 2010 to Chinese telecommunications company ZTE, the $470 million project was intended to establish surveillance cameras, communications networks and command centres for security agencies.

Approximately 2,000 surveillance cameras were planned for major cities, including Lagos and Abuja.

However, BusinessDay reported that several facilities inspected in Lagos had deteriorated, been vandalised or become abandoned.

Although the federal government established a management team in 2023 to rehabilitate the system, the extent of its restoration remains unclear.

Communities remain without electricity despite completed installations

Another project involved $7.5 million in financing for rural electricity infrastructure across Enugu, Cross River and Ogun states.

It was intended to bring electricity to 72 communities through the installation of transformers, electricity poles, distribution cables and meters.

However, an earlier investigation by the International Centre for Investigative Reporting found that several communities remained without electricity years after the infrastructure was installed.

In parts of Enugu State, transformers had deteriorated without ever being connected to functioning electricity supply.

Some communities reportedly raised their own money to establish alternative connections.

The investigation also found that some installations had been completed without adequate arrangements for commissioning and maintenance.

This illustrates how infrastructure projects can fail even after physical construction has been substantially completed.

World Bank's $250m water project fell short of expectations

The third project was the Third National Urban Water Sector Reform Project, approved by the World Bank in April 2014.

The programme was intended to improve water supply in Bauchi, Ekiti and Rivers states while strengthening the financial performance of public water utilities.

The original financing commitment was $250 million.

However, the programme closed in March 2021 without achieving several important objectives.

According to the World Bank's official completion report, the project received an overall outcome rating of moderately unsatisfactory.

Importantly, the $250 million was the originally approved amount, not the sum ultimately spent.

The World Bank reported actual disbursements of approximately $141.6 million, substantially below the original allocation.

This distinction matters because the project's shortcomings cannot be presented as proof that the entire $250 million was lost.

Nevertheless, the assessment demonstrates how approved development financing can produce results below expectations.

Nigeria repaid $200m for an incomplete telephone programme

The fourth project involved the National Rural Telephony Programme, designed to expand telephone access to underserved communities.

Its first phase was financed through a $200 million loan from China Exim Bank.

In March 2017, the House of Representatives raised concerns that the wider programme remained incomplete despite repayment of the loan's principal and interest.

The House also noted that the government had provided ₦300 million in counterpart funding for a second phase that had stalled.

According to the House's official proceedings of March 16, 2017, lawmakers warned that technological developments could render some of the equipment obsolete.

The programme illustrates how delayed implementation can reduce the usefulness of publicly financed infrastructure, even when loan repayment obligations have been met.

Nigeria's public debt has reached ₦166.79tn

The findings emerge as Nigeria's public debt continues to increase.

According to the Debt Management Office, the country's total public debt stood at approximately ₦166.79 trillion at the end of June 2026.

That compares with ₦87.38 trillion in June 2023.

The increase reflects several factors, including additional borrowing and changes in the naira value of foreign-currency obligations.

President Tinubu has argued that external borrowing is necessary to address Nigeria's infrastructure deficit and support economic growth.

Indeed, borrowing can finance productive investments that governments cannot immediately afford from available revenue.

However, the economic justification depends on whether projects are properly selected, completed and maintained.

The proposed $21.7 billion is also a borrowing request, not money that has already been received or spent.

What should happen before new loans are approved?

The investigation has renewed calls for greater transparency in public borrowing.

Experts interviewed by BusinessDay argued that lawmakers should examine individual projects, expected economic benefits and implementation arrangements before approving additional financing.

They also recommended publishing project costs, contractor information, implementation schedules and regular expenditure reports.

These measures could make it easier to identify delays and determine whether projects are delivering the services promised.

They would also allow the public to distinguish between loans approved, funds actually disbursed and money spent on completed infrastructure.

What this means for Nigerians

For Nigerians, the consequences of underperforming infrastructure extend beyond government debt figures.

An electricity project that does not deliver power leaves businesses dependent on expensive alternatives.

A water project that falls short of its objectives leaves households without dependable public services.

A security communications network that deteriorates may fail to provide the operational capabilities it was designed to deliver.

Meanwhile, government borrowing creates repayment obligations that must be considered alongside other public spending priorities.

The question is not simply whether Nigeria should borrow more money. It is whether the government can demonstrate that new loans will produce the infrastructure, services and economic benefits used to justify them.